Rediscover the best candy of your childhood with our huge selection of nostalgic candy! In this section, you’ll find everything from the turn of the 19th century, to the penny candy of the 1940s and 50s, to retro candy from the 1980s. It’s like uncovering the most delicious time-capsule ever!
Start your tasty trip down memory lane right here!
$ 3.00
The crunchy peanut butter and creamy milk chocolate that has been a quintessential fan favorite for more than 75 years. Named after that fashionable street in New York City, you may feel quite fashion forward snacking on this tasty treat.
This delicious treat is made with crunchy peanut butter and rich milk chocolate, giving you the perfect combination of sweet and salty flavors in every bite. Whether you're looking for a mid-day snack or a tasty indulgence after dinner, the 5th Avenue King Size Bar is sure to hit the spot.
And with its generous 3.4 oz. size, this candy bar is perfect for sharing with friends or enjoying all to yourself. So why settle for a regular-sized candy bar when you can have the king size version? Treat yourself like royalty with the 5th Avenue King Size Bar today!
So go ahead and indulge in a little bit of chocolatey and peanut buttery goodness with the 5th Avenue King Size Bar. It's the perfect way to satisfy your cravings and treat yourself like the king or queen that you are!
Kosher Certified Dairy
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, peanuts, corn syrup, vegetable oil [ palm kernel oil; palm oil]; cocoa butter; molasses; chocolate; contains 2% or less of: milk, cocoa, whey (milk), lactose (milk), milk fat, salt, soy lecithin, pgpr, emulsifier, artificial flavor, tbhq (preservative), sulfur dioxide, to maintain freshness.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 62.25
Really, "Sometimes, you feel like a nut," and Almond Joy gives you the go ahead to feel real joy with sweet, creamy shredded coconut and crisp, whole almonds, covered in rich milk chocolate. Who says nuttiness can't taste good?
Kosher Certified Dairy
Made in the USA
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn syrup, milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate, milk, lactose, milk fat, nonfat milk, soy lecithin PGPR, emulsifier), coconut, sugar, almonds (roasted in cocoa butter and/or sunflower oil), contains 2% or less of: partially hydrogenated vegetable oil, (soybean and palm oil), whey (milk), cocoa, salt, natural and artificial flavor, chocolate, soy lecithin, hydrolyzed milk protein, sodium metabisulfite, and sulfur dioxide, to maintain freshness), caramel color.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
Out of Stock
There are probably hundreds of reasons to buy a pack of Bazooka Original Bubble Gum. Maybe it’s your turn to stock up for your baseball team. Maybe you’re marching in a parade and need something to toss to the crowd. Maybe you’re feeling guilty about chewing all of your roommate’s yummy Bazooka Bubble Gum. We could go on and on, but there’s only one reason you really need to buy Bazooka Original Bubble Gum: It’s really fun to chew! The sweet, classic flavor tastes great, and blowing bubbles never gets old. Bazooka Original Bubble Gum is a lovable treat that can always make you feel like a kid again!
Tub Contains: 225 Pieces
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, gum base, glucose syrup, natural & artificial flavors, glycerine, citric acid, titanium dioxide, BHT (preservative), red 40 lake, red 40.
May contain soy.
PHENYLKETONURICS: CONTAINS PHENYLALANINE.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 21.50
Enjoy your favorite Bazooka gum flavor in one convenient pack with the Bazooka Wallet 10-piece. The traditional bubble gum flavor you know and love in perfect wallet size to take with you wherever you go!
Pack Includes Original Flavor and for a Limited Time, Grape Flavor!
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, gum base, glucose syrup, contains 2% of less of natural & artificial flavors, glycerin, citric acid, soy lecithin, BHT (preservative), red 40 lake.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 32.25
Were you ever told not to play with your food? Bonomo Chocolate Turkish Taffy is meant for you to have a good time. This interactive candy is fun for everyone. Make sure you have enough on hand for others because they will want to join in on the fun.
Also available in Banana, Strawberry, and Vanilla. Check out our Bonomo Turkish Taffy Collection!
Kosher Certified
Gluten Free
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn syrup, sugar, cocoa powder, mono and di-glycerides, egg whites, natural and artificial flavor, red 40 lake, yellow 5 lake, titanium dioxide, blue 1 lake, soy lecithin. Contains egg and soy.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 32.25
A childhood pleasure was going to the candy store to find that one candy choice that would last the longest (remember summer days are really long). The best choice was Bonomo Turkish Taffy and Strawberry is a great flavor. This one-of-a-kind candy amuses even the most computer-focused child. Grab a bar or two or three) and smack it against a hard surface to before you let it melt in your mouth. This candy is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Also available in Banana, Chocolate, and Vanilla.
Kosher Certified
Gluten Free
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn Syrup, sugar, mono and di-glycerides, egg albumen, FD&C red 3, blue 1, artificial and natural flavors, soy lecithin, contains egg and soy. Manufactured in a facility that also processes milk.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 1.50
Return to your childhood with Bonomo Vanilla Turkish Taffy. The original smack it and crack it taffy that entertained us as children is still as entertaining today. Introduce it to a new generation and become a superhero.
Also available in Banana, Strawberry, and Chocolate.
Kosher Certified
Gluten Free
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn syrup, sugar, mono and diglycerides, egg whites, natural and artificial flavor, soy lecithin.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 7.00
Boyer makes snacking even more fun with a Fun Bites version of their Butterscotch Smoother Peanut Butter Cups. Bite-sized cups of a smooth butterscotch coating filled with peanut butter. Great for Halloween trick-or-treat goodies.
Bag contains about 21 individually wrapped pieces.
Kosher Certified Dairy
Gluten Free
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, hydrogenated palm kernel oil, whey (milk). soy lecithin (an emulsifer), natural and artificial flavor, arificial color (contains f. d. & c yellow #6 lake, yellow #5 lake, and blue #2 lake), salt and coconut oil. peanut butter center – peanut butter, roasted peanuts, sugar, salt, lethicin oil, tenox 20a, dextrose.
Allergen Information: Manufactured in a facility that processes Egg, Milk & Coconut.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 26.50
Be a rock star back stage or a cowboy rounding up scoundrels in the backyard. Tasty and chewy bubble gum cigarettes were the candy you could play with before you ate them...and you still can! Actual clouds of sugary powder can be puffed out of these bubble gum cigarettes. Assorted stick flavors of bubble gum, grape and orange are packed neatly in these nostalgic cigarette boxes. The cigarettes themselves are wrapped in a white paper with an orange tip. Grab a pack of bubble gum cigarettes and shoot back in time to nostalgic candy land.
For single orders, availability of styles may vary. Please indicate style preference in notes at checkout and we will attempt to accommodate your request; otherwise one will be selected at random.
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, gum base, artificial flavors, artificial colors (FD&C red 3, blue 2, yellow 5), BHT as preservatives.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 11.00
Pretend to puff out sugar clouds with these classic candy cigarettes, then crunch on the sweet stick and repeat. It might be hard not to go through multiple packs in a day. Sugary candy sticks are packed in assorted cigarette boxes like, "Lucky Lights," or "Victory." Keep a couple packs around to take the “edge” off. The edge off your sugar craving that is. Nothing much has changed since you were a kid because these candy cigarettes are proudly made with the original recipe.
Made in Colombia
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Dextrose, corn starch, corn syrup, tapioca, beef gelatin, artificial flavors.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by man
