4,000+ 5* Reviews
Proudly Serving For 10+ Years
Free Shipping Over $300
4,000+ 5* Reviews
Proudly Serving For 10+ Years
Free Shipping Over $300
Yes, we know that peanut butter is delicious straight from the jar, but it is extraordinary when it’s used as an ingredient in candy! Our peanut butter department has scores of tasty ways to get this miracle food to your mouth and every one of them is absolutely fantastic. Save yourself the trouble of making a triple decker PB&J sandwich and order some of our awesome peanut butter and peanut butter flavored candy instead!
$ 31.25
The crunchy peanut butter and creamy milk chocolate that has been a quintessential fan favorite for more than 75 years. Named after that fashionable street in New York City, you may feel quite fashion forward snacking on this tasty treat. You will want to have enough of this hard-to-find bar on hand.
Kosher Certified Dairy
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, peanuts, corn syrup, vegetable oil (cocoa butter, palm kernel, palm, shea, sunflower and/or safflower oil), molasses, chocolate, contains 2% or less of: milk, cocoa, whey (milk), lactose (milk), milk fat, salt, soy lecithin, pgpr, emulsifier, artificial flavor, tbhq (preservative), sulfur dioxide, to maintain freshness.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 33.00
Get ready to experience the ultimate snack sensation with Atkinson's timeless and beloved Chick-O-Stick in...
$ 49.00
What could be better than the crispy peanut butter and coconut flavors of Chick-O-Sticks candy?...
$ 17.25
Love the taste of peanut butter but don't want too much sugar in your diet?...
$ 7.00
Boyer makes snacking even more fun with a Fun Bites version of their Butterscotch Smoother Peanut...
$ 7.00
Bite-sized milk chocolate cups filled with creamy peanut butter, from the makers of the adored...
$ 1.75
It's a Better Butterfinger! Butterfinger introduces a new and improved recipe – now with more crispety, crunchety, peanut buttery goodness. The recipe includes carefully selected U.S. grown peanuts with a rich chocolate coating. It also features a double-layer, higher-quality packaging material to lock in freshness.
Kosher Certified Dairy
Gluten Free
Made in the USA
UTZ Certified
$ 24.75
Easy to Eat! The same crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery taste that you love in a Butterfinger bar in easy-to-eat, bite-sized pieces. Grab this box on your way out to the movie theater, put one in your desk drawer, makes a great anytime snack.
Box contains about 2.5 servings.
No Artificial Flavors or Colors
Kosher Certified Dairy
Note: Packaging may vary.
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Peanuts, Vegetable Oil (Palm Kernel and Palm Oil), Peanut Flour, Nonfat Milk, Less than 2% of Cocoa, Milk, Salt, Soy Lecithin, Natural Flavor, Annatto Color.
Contains: Milk, Peanut, Soy.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 9.25
Don't let the name scare you -- this Atkinson's delight is for the peanut butter and...
$ 0.50
Don't let the name scare you -- this Atkinson's delight is for the peanut butter and...
$ 0.75
Don't let the name scare you -- this Atkinson's delight is for the peanut butter and...
$ 2.50
Don't let the name scare you -- this Atkinson's delight is for the peanut butter...
$ 1.75
A new peanut butter cup from Boyer, the makers of Mallo Cups and Smoothie Cups....
$ 7.00
Bite-sized versions of the delicious milk chocolate peanut butter cups with Clark Crunch, perfect for...
$ 4.25
Romeo and Juliet. Cleopatra and Antony. Peanut Butter and Chocolate. Some romances turn out better...
$ 4.25
A white “chocolate” version of the incredible Cleo’s Peanut Butter Cups. The vegan solution to the White...
$ 50.25
Freshly roasted Virginia peanuts, doubly drenched in rich, dark chocolate. 3 lb. Bag Contains Approximately...
$ 28.75
A twist on the classic milk chocolate giant peanut butter cup! Rich and full of...
$ 28.75
Creamy and smooth peanut butter filling surrounded by rich dark chocolate. One-Pound Box Contains: approximately...
$ 17.25
Rich and creamy peanut butter filling surrounded by sugar free chocolate individually wrapped. If you...
$ 11.50
Rich and creamy peanut butter filling surrounded by sugar free chocolate. Each 7 oz. Tub...
$ 34.00
Dutch Delights Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are sure to delight anyone who eats them! Smooth peanut butter covered with a delicious milk chocolate coating. Get this treat in a bulk bag to have enough to share with friends or to keep them for yourself!
2 LB Bag Contains: approximately 55 pieces
3 LB Bag Contains: approximately 80 pieces
