Buttery Candy

Lots of Delicious Flavors

Premium Quality Candy

Perfect Gifts for any Occasion

Even the most naturally delicious food on earth would get exponentially better with a dollop of butter! The salty-sweet flavor that enhances everything from plain old white bread, to popcorn to your favorite cakes and cookies also works wonders when it takes a starring role in candy, especially the old-time favorite, butterscotch! Explore our butter flavored candy today!

Reese's Peanut Butter Santas 9.1 oz. Bag

In stock 12 left

$ 10.50

Quick Shop

Reese's Peanut Butter Snowman 5 oz.

In stock 2 left

$ 9.25

Quick Shop

Reese's Peanut Butter Tree 1.2 oz.

In stock 1 left

from $ 2.25

Quick Shop

Reppert's Peanut Butter Fall Nonpareils - Bulk Bags - Visit www.allcitycandy.com for great candy and delicious treats.

Reppert's Peanut Butter Rainbow Nonpareils - Bulk Bags

In stock 7 left

from $ 17.25

Quick Shop

Roses Brand Buttermints 3 lb. Bulk Bag

Out of Stock

$ 19.00

Quick Shop

Sold Out

Russell Stover Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Heart 1.3 oz.

In stock 32 left

$ 3.00

Quick Shop

Sugar Free Chick-O-Sticks Crunchy Peanut Butter & Toasted Coconut Candy

Out of Stock

from $ 3.00

Quick Shop

Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars - 3.75-oz. Bag

In stock 25 left

$ 4.75

Quick Shop

Sunrise Butterscotch Disc Wrapped Hard Candy 3 lb. Bulk Bag

In stock 14 left

$ 19.00

Quick Shop

Walnut Creek Butter Pecan Fudge Cup 3 oz.

In stock 10 left

$ 3.00

Quick Shop

Walnut Creek Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge Cup 3 oz.

In stock 4 left

$ 1.25

Quick Shop

Walnut Creek Peanut Butter Fudge Cup 3 oz.

In stock 16 left

$ 3.00

Quick Shop

Werther's Original Caramel Hard Candies - 1.8-oz. Roll

In stock 6 left

from $ 2.50

Quick Shop

Thank You For The Great Reviews

from 4059 reviews

Jawbreakers

Love my jawbreakers! I have ordered from All City Candy before and they promptly send the candy along with a Thank You item. I have told my family and friends about them, Great company!! Thank you

Chris J.

Assorted Jaw Breakers - 3 lb Bulk Bag

03/13/2024

Hearts

This company is top notch and A + highly recommend

Ronald L.

Sanded Cinnamon Jelly Hearts - Bulk Bags

03/08/2024

PEZ Orange candy is the Best

The Orange PEZ candy I found on All City Candy’s website brings back great memories from childhood. It was always a special time going to the 7 Eleven near our home in Seattle and getting a new PEZ dispenser with refills.

M. G.

PEZ Orange Candy Refills .29 oz. - 1 LB Bulk Bag

09/07/2023

Great value Great candy

We were so excited to open our mystery bag. There were some of our favorites and some things we’ve never heard of!

Sara M.

Mystery Candy Bag

10/14/2022

Sweets for the sweet

I was really happy when I found this site because they have fair prices and get it to you quickly. I love those giant peppermint 2lb. logs and the only ones I could find were $20.00 a pound which means $40.00 for the log a price I'm not willing to pay. I got 2 of the logs here for less than 1 at other sites. Their candy is fresh and delicious.

Barbara M.

Now and Later Banana Candy

09/19/2022

Halloween Candy Corn

I am very happy with my purchase from All City Candy. I love the individually wrapped candy corn to pass out at Halloween along with other nostalgic candy. It arrived quickly and was packed very nicely. I will be ordering more old-time candy from All City Candy.

Terri R.

Zachary Candy Corn Individually Wrapped 1 oz. Packs 2 lb. Bulk Bag

09/04/2022

Totally Yum!!

I have bought this sponge candy several times now & it is amazingly good!! Fresh and yummy! The value is also amazing, think about how much you pay at a candy store!! I strongly approve this business!!

Jeanette S.

Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy Bulk Bags

08/29/2022

Mystery bag

I love getting the mystery bag. My grandkids can’t wait to come and look through it to see what’s new. I would love to see a retro candy mystery bag so my grandkids can see the candy I had as a child. Love All City!

Shirley K.

08/20/2022

Fast delivery!

I live in Chicago and was looking for a product that is a special edition. I couldn’t find it anywhere and did an internet search and found All City. I ordered my candy and delivery was fast. Decided to get the same candy for someone else and again quick fast and candy is fresh! Not to mention it is packed to perfection. They will always get my business!

LScott

Haribo 100th Anniversary Edition Watermelon Bears 4 oz. Bag

07/11/2022

Best Buckeyes Ever!

These are so delicious and honestly the best buckeyes we have ever tried, highly recommend!!

Sergio C.

Ohio Made Waggoner Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Buckeye Candy Bulk Bags

05/11/2022

Fast and Delicious!

Received my 5 bags of Cherry Tootsie Pops faster than expected, and found them fresh and delicious. Each bag weighed a few ounces over 2 lbs, so kudos for delivering as promised. Thanks for a top notch experience!

Nancy P.

Cherry Tootsie Pops - 2 LB Bulk Bag

05/03/2022

Perfect treat for ALL AGES!

I live in a retirement home. I try different goodies on a shelf outside of my apartment 👏EVERYONE LOVED SMARTEES!
Not too sweet, just the right sis, and easy to get open. Their kids & grandkids all love these affordable fun treats!!!
Thanks ALL CITY!!! You make it all possible!!! 👏😘🤣

Debbie

Smarties Candy Rolls - Case of 160

04/18/2022

Exactly what I wanted

I had searched everywhere for these specific mints and this was the only place that had them. Customer service was great and product shipped fast. Definitely will order from this vendor again for my next event.

D.T.

Pastel Green Mint Nonpareils - Bulk Bags

04/17/2022

Wonderful candy store!

I am delighted with my purchase of peek-a-boo chocolate eggs. The candy is yummy and the little chick inside is a fun surprise! The order was processed very quickly, and they even took the time to refund the purchase of the cold pack which they said was not needed. (too cold outside still!) The order was securely packaged and I found they had included a little extra sweet treat which made me smile.
This is a company with great customer service and wonderful products. I give them an A+ AND 5 stars!

Patricia C.

Easter Peek-a-Boo Milk Chocolate Egg and Marshmallow Chick

03/28/2022

A colorful, tasty treat

I was looking for assorted Easter candy for a few little goodie bags, and specifically wanted a gummie type item with a particular texture. I didn't want it too squishy, nor hard enough to pull your fillings out. I was happy when my package arrived and I saw (and tasted) the assortment. The candy met all my specifications (and I can be pretty picky).

I have enjoyed some of these candies myself, although the majority were purchased for holiday treat bags. I am sure the recipients will be just as impressed as I was. Generally I don't eat a lot of candy or sugar. If I am going to treat myself, I want it to be GOOD candy. This is a great place for good candy!

The service here was just as good as the products. My order was packed carefully and shipped almost immediately. I am across the country and was amazed how quickly my order arrived. Every step of the process was easy. It is a pleasure to do business with a quality company offering great products. Thank you!

Kathy J.

JuJu Easter Mix - Bulk Bags

03/22/2022