Mystery Candy Bag

Subscribe to All City Candy Emails and We'll Send you a Coupon for 10% Off! Sign Up

4,000+ 5* Reviews
Proudly Serving For 10+ Years
Free Shipping Over $300

Mystery Candy Bag

SKU: ACC-MYSTERYBAG10

$ 10.00 USD $ 15.00

Free Shipping Over $300

in stock

Product Information

Be surprised with a sweet $15-value assortment of candy and treats for $10.

Inside this boring brown paper bag is a colorful and sugar-filled adventure ready to jump out and right into your mouth. Open one up, but be careful not to be blinded by the bright rainbow light.

Have fun!

Ingredients: See Individual Packaging.

We have not opened the mystery bag yet but everything looks great. We order a bag of sweet and sour suckered with the mystery bag, we even have a extra piece of candy in the box🥰

Thank you so much, JaMesha! 🍬 Our Candy Crew can't wait for you to discover what's inside. Enjoy every surprise!

I was actually very impressed with my first order. I ordered a mystery bag and they accepted the instructions on what I didn't want included.

I will definitely order again.

Thank you so much, LaVette! 🍬 Welcome to the All City Candy family. Our Candy Crew can't wait to put together your next order!

Definitely not worth it

I was very disappointed with my mystery bag. It definitely was not worth the $10 I paid for it and quite a few of the items in there were sour and I don't eat sour candy. I definitely won't buy it again.

We're so sorry this one missed the mark, and thank you for letting us know. 🍬 For future orders, you're always welcome to leave a note at checkout about anything you'd like us to skip, and we'll do our best to tailor your bag. We'd love the chance to make your next experience a sweeter one. 💛

Great selection for the price!! This is my 2nd time ordering this and will definitely be ordering again!!!!

Great candy. Good variety

Thank you so much for sharing this. We are thrilled you loved the variety. We hope to see you again soon!

1 2 3

For more information Click here

Our Most Popular Products

Chocolate Candy

View Category

Decorating Candy

View Category

King Sized Candy

View Category

Gum & Bubble Gum

View Category

Thank You For The Great Reviews

from 4697 reviews

thank you so much for my candy my gummy worms that's my favorite candy you guys can just on time and you guys can't go too that's what I love and have a wonderful night take care God bless all right bye I'm very satisfied what I have all right bye

Shuron G.

10/15/2026

I love it? Thank you!!!

Tamerra

10/14/2026

its delicious 😋

Debby L.

10/13/2026

fast shipping and great product

Garry

10/12/2026

I love anything Santa and have several other Pez Santa’s and wanted to add the mini one to those that I already have. I just happen to find the Santa while going through what All City Candy offers.

Janet

10/09/2026

These are fresh and look great and don’t expire until 2028. I bought some other Cinnamon Santa’s off of Amazon (big mistake) and when they arrive they looked very chalky and stale and on top of that they expire in January 2027. I will buy all of my Cinnamon Santa’s every fall from All City Candy from now on!

Janet

10/09/2026

I bought this item years ago and was thrilled to be able to find it on All City Candy’s website. The kids are going to love getting it for Halloween.

Janet

10/09/2026

These are my favorite!! Always arrive perfect!

Jennifer

10/07/2026

Great service!

All City Candy has always been so responsive to my orders! Their shipping is fast and their product arrives in great condition! My family & friends really enjoy the Lemans Football mints! I will definitely order from All City Candy again!

Linda H.

10/07/2026

A Fall Staple

I recently ordered three bags of Brach’s Mellowcreme Pumpkins, and I’ve already eaten two. Yes, they’re that addictive! These classic fall candies strike the perfect balance of creamy texture and sweet, nostalgic flavor. Each pumpkin melts in your mouth and tastes like pure autumn happiness. I’m definitely going to need to reorder soon because these disappeared way too fast. Candy Corn might get a bad rap because the size doesn't allow it to be as creamy, but I absolutely won’t stand for any Mellowcreme Pumpkin slander. They are delicious.

10/07/2026

we LOVE Jelly Belly !! and to find them in bulk at this price point? even better! keep 'em coming... Coz we'll keep buying!

Kevin

10/07/2026

love it

Gary J.

10/05/2026

We have not opened the mystery bag yet but everything looks great. We order a bag of sweet and sour suckered with the mystery bag, we even have a extra piece of candy in the box🥰

JaMesha

10/05/2026

Spicy!

Nice strong ginger flavor.

This was my 7th order and all have been perfect; fast shipping, safe packaging and fresh product.

DLB

10/04/2026

I was actually very impressed with my first order. I ordered a mystery bag and they accepted the instructions on what I didn't want included.

I will definitely order again.

LaVette H.

10/03/2026