Rediscover the best candy of your childhood with our huge selection of nostalgic candy! In this section, you’ll find everything from the turn of the 19th century, to the penny candy of the 1940s and 50s, to retro candy from the 1980s. It’s like uncovering the most delicious time-capsule ever!
Start your tasty trip down memory lane right here!
Out of Stock
They couldn’t have picked a better name for these famously sweet and delightfully creamy bite-sized treats!
Do you love chewy and creamy caramel treats that melt in your mouth and leave you feeling satisfied? Then you'll love Sugar Babies Soft Milk Caramels!
These delicious caramel candies are made with creamy milk, providing you with a rich and indulgent taste experience. And with their soft and chewy texture, they'll keep you coming back for more.
Whether you're enjoying them during a movie night or as a quick snack on the go, Sugar Babies Soft Milk Caramels are the perfect treat for any occasion. And with their convenient theater box packaging, they're easy to take with you wherever you go.
So why settle for boring and bland candy when you can enjoy the rich and creamy taste of Sugar Babies Soft Milk Caramels? Indulge your sweet tooth and treat yourself to these irresistible candies today!
Kosher Certified Dairy
Gluten Free
Peanut Free/Nut Free
Color is represented as accurately as possible, but actual product color may vary from photographs.
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, invert sugar, partially hydrogenated soybean oil, dry whole milk, modified food starch, whey, natural and artificial flavors, confectioner's glaze, salt, caramel color, artificial colors (FD&C yellow 5, red 40, yellow 6, blue 1), soy lecithin, white mineral oil. Eggs may be present.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 26.00
The classic caramel lollipop, in a junior-sized version.
Pops measure approximately 2-1/2" (caramel), plus a 2" stick.
3 lb. Bag Contains: approximately 98 individually wrapped pieces
Kosher Certified Dairy
Gluten Free
Peanut Free/Nut Free
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Corn syrup, sugar, partially hydrogenated soybean oil, dry whole milk, whey, natural and artificial flavors, salt, soya lecithin.
Contains a bioengineered food ingredient.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 92.00
Not only is Kansas famous for Dorothy and her trip to Oz, it is home to one of the best Old fashioned chocolate marshmallow cups ever. This family owned and operated company is now entering its fifth generation and is focused on only making Valomilk Candy Cups. The milk they use to make their chocolate is locally sourced and they use pure vanilla, not artificial flavoring. With devotion like that, there is no need to strike down a wicked witch, just simply order some for yourself and those you love.
Made in the USA
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Milk chocolate (sugar, cocoa butter, dry whole milk, chocolate liquor, soy lecithin, vanilla and salt), marshmallow (corn syrup, distilled water, pure vanilla, egg whites and salt). Contains soy, milk, and eggs.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to produce labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 33.00
You loved them as a kid, and you still love them as an adult. You may feel funny taking the big milk carton box into the movies with you, but this theater box is easily slipped into a bag and the perfect size to eat while watching your flick. Mix them in with your popcorn or top your ice cream with them for a delicious twist.
Kosher Certified Dairy
Made in the USA
Each box contains approximately 58 pieces
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, partially hydrogenated palm kernel oil, whey (milk), malted milk (barley malt, whey flour, milk, salt, sodium bicarbonate), cocoa, contains 2% or less of: resinous glaze, sorbitan tristearate, soy lecithin, salt, natural and artificial flavor, calcium carbonate, tapioca dextrin.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 3.50
The original malted milk balls. Malt Ball fans will be thrilled with this bag of their original favorite candy. Crunchy malted milk balls covered in delicious milk chocolate make for an irresistible treat. Get a bag today to share with friends and family or to keep all for yourself!
Kosher Certified Dairy
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, partially hydrogenated palm kernel oil, whey (milk), malted milk (barley malt, whey flour, milk, salt, sodium bicarbonate), cocoa, contains 2% or less of: resinous glaze, sorbitan tristearate, soy lecithin, salt, natural and artificial flavor, calcium carbonate, tapioca dextrin.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.
$ 31.25
A tasty combination of toasted coconut covering creamy peanut butter. Since 1930, Zagnut has been blessing us with great taste and it hasn't disappointed since. Buy one or buy the case, if you loved it as a child or want to introduce your child (grandchild) to this delicious bar, now is your chance.
Kosher Certified Dairy
Made in the USA
Follow All City Candy on Social Media:
Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Pinterest
Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, peanuts, toasted coconut, molasses, partially hydrogenated palm kernel and palm oil, contains 2% or less of: salt, vegetable oil (cocoa butter, palm, shea, sunflower and/or safflower oil), cocoa, chocolate, soy lecithin, milk, lactose (milk), whey (milk), milk fat, nonfat milk, artificial flavor, TBHQ (preservative), artificial color (yellow 6 lake), cocoa butter, PGRP and sorbitan tristearate as emulsifiers.
Ingredients and nutritional information provided by manufacturer and considered accurate at time of posting. Refer to product labeling or contact manufacturer directly for current data.